Why I Do not (& Will not) Name Tesla’s Charging Plug “NACS”

February 1, 2023

1

For the final couple of months, one thing has actually been grinding my gears, however I figured it was a fad that was going to go away. When Tesla renamed its charging connector and referred to as it the “North American Charging Customary,” Tesla followers adopted the NACS acronym in a single day. My preliminary response was that it was a foul concept to only change the phrase for one thing as a result of it will confuse individuals who don’t comply with the EV area that intently. Not everyone follows the Tesla weblog like a non secular textual content, and if I simply modified the phrase with out warning, folks may not even know what I used to be speaking about.

However, as I thought of it extra, I noticed that language is a strong factor. Certain, you’ll be able to translate a phrase from one language to a different, however you’ll be able to’t all the time carry over the entire that means. All you’re doing with translation is discovering the phrase that’s closest in that means. Typically, you could find a phrase that’s nearly precisely the identical in that means as a phrase in one other language. Different occasions, the that means is both barely completely different or far sufficient off to end in misunderstandings.

What I noticed is that when any individual says “Tesla plug,” they’re solely referring to the plug that Tesla’s automobiles have. It means nothing kind of. However, the time period “NACS” carries a very completely different that means. It’s not solely Tesla’s plug, however it’s THE plug that each one automobiles may and possibly ought to have. It additionally means that it’s a time period larger than the US, like NAFTA. It means that some supranational entity has chosen it to be the plug for North America.

However that couldn’t be farther from the reality. I gained’t attempt to let you know that CCS occupies such a lofty seat, both. There’s no North American entity that may even dictate such issues. In actual fact, the concept of a North American Union has been a well-liked conspiracy principle for fairly some time, particularly within the right-wing circles Elon Musk is now pleasant with, however whereas “globalists” would possibly need to implement such a union, it doesn’t exist right this moment and should by no means exist. So, there’s actually no one to make it official.

I don’t convey this up out of any animosity towards Tesla or Elon Musk. I actually assume that CCS and Tesla’s plug are actually on equal footing. CCS is most well-liked by most different automakers, and thus is most well-liked by CharIN (an trade entity, not a authorities entity). However, however, Tesla is the largest EV automaker by far, and has principally the most effective quick charging community, so its alternative is simply as necessary.

Nevertheless, does it even matter that there’s no normal? The heading on the following part has my reply to that.

We Don’t Even Want A Customary Plug

In the end, we don’t even want a charging normal! Not like prior format wars, it’s doable to easily adapt. A VHS-to-Betamax adapter wouldn’t have labored. The identical was true for 8-tracks and cassettes, and for Blu-Ray vs HD-DVD. These requirements have been incompatible sufficient with one another that you just had to decide on one or the opposite. However the CCS, CHAdeMO, and Tesla plugs are simply electrical. There are already adapters between all of them.

Maybe extra importantly, Tesla is already planning to construct CCS adapters into its Supercharger stations within the type of “Magic Docks.”

So that is how Tesla will assist CCS at US Superchargers.

The Magic Dock. You pull out the Tesla connector in the event you simply want that, or the bigger dock in the event you want CCS.

Ought to make retrofits a bit of cake — low capex. https://t.co/P91XOIRlH0 pic.twitter.com/3DgJpH932h

— Complete Mars Catalog (@WholeMarsBlog) January 23, 2023

So, even Tesla is aware of that different producers aren’t going to undertake the Tesla plug. It doesn’t even assume it’s the “North American Charging Customary”, so why ought to I name it that? Why ought to any of us?

The one cheap argument I can consider for the “NACS” identify is that it’s Tesla’s North American normal plug. On that depend, it completely is. In Europe, Tesla has been compelled to undertake the CCS2 plug. In China, it’s been compelled to make use of the GB/T connector, which is even much less elegant as a result of it makes use of two plugs as a substitute of only one just like the CCS connector. North America is the one place the place we are inclined to worth free markets over regulation to the purpose the place governments didn’t mandate a plug by authorities fiat.

However, necessity is the mom of invention. If the federal government gained’t dictate a normal, adapters are right here to make it utterly pointless. In the end, all automobiles will be capable to cost in any respect stations, even when it means the station wants a built-in Magic Dock, or in any other case builds within the adapter like EVgo does for Tesla’s automobiles.

An EVgo station with built-in CHAdeMO-to-Tesla adapter. Picture supplied by EVgo.

I’m Not Certain A Future Unified Customary Will Occur, Both

We maintain seeing the demand for energy in charging rise and rise and rise, however there comes a degree the place that’s a foul concept. Making our automobiles vitality hogs as a substitute of specializing in effectivity makes them not solely much less environmentally pleasant, however dearer to construct, cost, and function. Whereas folks want to see electrical automobiles that cost in solely 5 minutes, it’s actually not going to be value what that may price to combine into gentle automobiles.

The place extra energy can be helpful is in heavier automobiles, and that’ll occur through the MCS connector. Semi vans, and probably future medium and one-ton vans, will in all probability have an MCS plug to get the upper ranges of energy that can be wanted to cost their really huge battery packs in an inexpensive timeframe. However will there be a Tesla automotive with charging over a megawatt? Most likely not.

CCS can be nice already, with the Kia EV6 going from 10–80% in simply 18 minutes on lower than 350 kW of energy. That’s over 200 miles of vary added to the pack within the time it takes to go pee, stretch your legs, and seize a soda. Anyone who wants quicker charging additionally wants a catheter and doubtless love-triangle astronaut diapers to go greater than 3 hours between charging stops.

So, absent some actual want for a brand new plug, we in all probability gained’t see one for fairly a very long time until a very international normal emerges that may be advantageous for firms to undertake.

Featured picture by EVgo.