Tesla and Elon Musk have been singing the praises of 4680 battery cells for nearly two years. The world of electrical automobiles is all atwitter — it’s best to pardon the expression — about this wondrous new battery expertise. However what precisely is the story right here? In a weblog submit on Medium, Will Lockett asks some probing questions and comes up with some disturbing solutions.
“In September 2020, Musk revealed to the market Tesla’s 4680 battery and, at face worth, it seemed like it could revolutionize the EV world. It promised to slash the fee per kWh by 56%, produce extra energy than its predecessor, are available in a structural pack (rising the crash security of the automobile), be extra resilient to provide chain points, be higher for the setting, and even cost faster. With such a battery, Tesla may lastly supply their $25,000 EV, paving the way in which for the Cybertruck and second-generation Roadster to develop into a actuality. Two years down the highway, Tesla is barely simply beginning to put 4680 packs into its automobiles, however latest teardowns have proven that one thing fishy is occurring, because it appears Tesla is perhaps pulling the wool over our eyes.”
Lockett says the 4680 has a number of distinctive and groundbreaking options. Its bigger measurement — 46 mm in diameter by 80 mm lengthy — permits every battery pack to make use of fewer particular person cells, every with a better capability than a conventional 2170 cell. That makes the manufacturing and meeting prices of the battery pack decrease. As a substitute of being bolted in the way in which they’re in a conventional battery pack, they’re set in a resin brick, which permits the pack to develop into a structural member of the automobile. This additionally lowers manufacturing prices.
The 4680 battery additionally reportedly had some vital inner adjustments. Somewhat than a graphite anode, it was supposed to make use of a silicon anode. That ought to make the 4680 much more power dense and capable of cost and discharge at a lot quicker charges. Somewhat than utilizing the standard NMC 811 (80% nickel, 10% manganese, and 10% cobalt) cathode, the 4680 was supposed to make use of a cobalt-free, high-manganese, low-nickel cathode. The cathode and anode are additionally stated to be dry coated, which hurries up manufacturing and additional reduces prices.
Lastly, Lockett writes, relatively than having a small tab connecting the anode and cathode to the optimistic and unfavorable terminals of the battery, the 4680 has a strip of metallic on every finish of the rolled up battery that’s folded down after rolling to make a flat plate-like metallic floor that connects to the terminals. This makes manufacturing cheaper by having fewer meeting steps and reduces the facility bottleneck within the terminals, making ultra-fast charging and high-power outputs potential.
Houston, we now have an issue. Lockett factors out that impartial analysts like Sandy Munro have discovered that the 4680 battery cells getting used right now in some Tesla automobiles comprise nearly not one of the groundbreaking options Musk puffed up again in 2020. They’re 46 mm in diameter and 80 mm lengthy and they’re tabless. “However every thing else is lacking,” Lockett says. Right here’s extra:
“These teardowns confirmed that the anode materials is graphite and the cathode materials is NMC 811, that means its inner chemistry is equivalent to its older 2170 cell. This implies no superior charging speeds or greater power density. It additionally implies that this cell continues to be making use of environmentally damaging and humanitarian-troubling cobalt mining and stays susceptible to nickel value rises. To make issues worse, the cell partitions are 3 times thicker than a 2170 cell, additional driving down power density.
“It is extremely laborious to determine whether or not the electrode is dry coated or not, as each strategies of coating do the identical job, and the outcomes look equivalent. However this technique is the factor inflicting Tesla to battle to ramp up manufacturing as a result of it’s a bottleneck. Every time they attempt to produce extra cells, the standard of the dry coating drops, and only some cells go high quality management, inflicting the fee per cell to rise dramatically. But when they will nail this tech, the fee per cell will plummet massively. It stands to purpose that if the present 4680 cells have been dry coated, Tesla could be making an enormous deal of it. So, in all chance, the present 4680 cells most likely aren’t dry coated.
“Removed from being a groundbreaking, industry-shaking battery, it appears the current 4680 is only a cumbersome model of the batteries we have already got.”
There Are 4680 Price Benefits
Even with out all the advantages promised, the 4680 battery cells do decrease prices of producing, Lockett says. “A 4680 pack for a Mannequin Y prices Tesla $7,400, which is 33% cheaper than the equal 2170 pack. But, that is nonetheless a method off the goal of 56% cheaper and with none upgrades when it comes to power density, vary, efficiency, or cost speeds.” Then he will get to the meat of his argument.
“I, together with many different folks, have thought that, on the very least, the present 4680 is greater than only a bigger cell. Tesla has been very sneaky by not being open in regards to the nature of those 4680 cells. It nearly seems like their silence is a tactic to make folks suppose they’re shopping for a automobile with a next-gen battery in it. When in actuality, they aren’t.
“However ought to we actually be aggravated at Tesla for this? In spite of everything, issues like silicon anodes, dry-coated electrodes, and cobalt-free cathodes are all on the bleeding fringe of expertise. Can we actually anticipate Tesla to pack all of this right into a battery after which produce it on a big scale at filth low cost costs?
“No, we shouldn’t. It is smart for Musk to incrementally introduce these points into the battery manufacturing line. Begin with the straightforward components like the shape issue, tabless design, and structural battery pack. Then begin introducing the distinctive inner chemistry and at last begin dry-coating. This manner, every of those points’ manufacturing strategies could be developed and refined earlier than shifting on to the following. Subsequently, you create a sturdy, dependable, and environment friendly manufacturing line as shortly as potential.
“What isn’t okay is the silence over what is definitely occurring with the 4680 improvement and manufacturing. The truth that these teardowns have unveiled this relatively than Tesla themselves saying how 4680 improvement and manufacturing goes is shameful. It results in many considering they’re shopping for one thing that they aren’t. Furthermore, this provides to the rising notion that Tesla is, behind the scenes, relatively a shady and morally ambiguous firm.”
Ouch! A shady and morally ambiguous firm? That may be a highly effective indictment. However wait. There’s extra.
“So sure, one thing fishy is going on at Tesla, and the unbelievable 4680 battery continues to be in manufacturing hell. I might be trying to get my act collectively if I have been Musk. It isn’t simply Tesla within the EV sport anymore. Even when Tesla lastly will get round to creating a 4680 with all of the promised specs, firms like CATL, ONE, and Quantumscape are all producing open-market batteries which have the potential to not solely match however blow the 4680 out of the water. Any extra delays and Tesla will begin wanting antiquated.
“The rose tinted glasses are additionally beginning to slip. The general public is changing into extra conscious of how Tesla treats its workforce, how they method the precise to restore, and now how questionable their PR is. If Tesla continues this fashion, it gained’t be the golden boy of the EV world for for much longer.”
The Takeaway
I’m not a battery scientist nor have I ever performed one on TV. However when the 4680 information first surfaced, no person knew a lot about what was inside and Tesla was fairly quiet about technical particulars. Tesla has shut down its media relations workplace and doesn’t reply to any questions from the press. The one information we get in regards to the firm comes from Elon’s tweets, quarterly convention requires shareholders, and particular occasions like AI Day.
It’s a scenario that invitations commentators like Will Lockett to see skulduggery and malfeasance all over the place. It’s a type of unforced errors that appears to end result from Elon Musk’s dictatorial management fashion.
Are folks entitled to know specifics in regards to the batteries that energy their electrical automobiles? That doesn’t appear unreasonable. Tesla does itself no favors by its obstinacy. Transparency isn’t laborious. The truth is, it’s good enterprise. Elon’s insistence on decreasing a cone of silence round his enterprise pursuits creates self-inflicted wounds. He ought to know higher.
Featured picture courtesy of Panasonic.
Respect CleanTechnica’s originality and cleantech information protection? Contemplate changing into a CleanTechnica Member, Supporter, Technician, or Ambassador — or a patron on Patreon.
Do not wish to miss a cleantech story? Join day by day information updates from CleanTechnica on e mail. Or comply with us on Google Information!
Have a tip for CleanTechnica, wish to promote, or wish to counsel a visitor for our CleanTech Discuss podcast? Contact us right here.
