Ph.D. in Chemistry, École Polytechnique
Jan 16, 2023
Hydrogen gas cells vs. lithium-ion batteries: two distinctive applied sciences powering electrical automobiles (EVs).
Electrical automobiles, EVs, are seen as the way forward for mobility. In 2022, they account for six% of all automobile gross sales within the US, with a goal of fifty% by 2030. Some nations go even additional. In Europe, the sale of recent petrol vehicles will likely be banned beginning in 2035.
On this technical revolution, oil is changed by electrical energy and our fuel tank by lithium-ion batteries. Nonetheless, like all new applied sciences, lithium-ion just isn’t with out its flaws, and a challenger, the hydrogen gas cell, might additionally get its share of the pie.
Let’s evaluation each applied sciences and discover out what the way forward for electrical automobiles seems to be like.
Climatebiz consultants design, analysis, fact-check & edit all work meticulously.
Affiliate Disclaimer
Climatebiz is reader-supported. We might earn an affiliate fee while you purchase by means of hyperlinks on our website.
DELTA Max + 110W $600 Off
Use our coupon code to seize this restricted deal from EcoFlow whereas it lasts. Again up your own home throughout energy outages with the DELTA Max + 110W photo voltaic panel.
Hydrogen gas cells vs. lithium-ion batteries: what’s the distinction?
There’s a main distinction between hydrogen gas cells and lithium-ion batteries:
A gas cell generates electrical energy from hydrogen (H2) and oxygen (O2), whereas lithium-ion battery shops and provides electrical energy and requires an exterior supply for charging.
As proven beneath, the gas cell is all the time coupled with a hydrogen tank and a lithium-ion battery in an EV.
Hydrogen gas cells and lithium batteries each use (electro)chemical reactions to generate or retailer electrical energy.
Their energetic supplies and core reactions are totally different, however they share the identical components:
- Cathode.
- Anode.
- Separator (membrane).
- Electrolyte.
- Present collector.
Let’s rapidly evaluation their working precept.
Hydrogen gas cell: working precept
Hydrogen fuel (the gas) is fed on the anode, and air enters by the cathode. A catalyst, normally platinum, on the anode separates hydrogen into protons (h+) and electrons (e–). The electrons circulate into {the electrical} circuit, and the protons journey from the anode to the cathode to react with oxygen and generate water and warmth as a by-product.
Lithium-ion battery: working precept
A lithium-ion battery is a tool that converts electrical energy into chemical vitality. An electrochemical reversible response can retailer electrical energy (charging) or provide electrical energy (discharging).
In a lithium-ion battery, lithium ions (Li+) are exchanged between the anode and the cathode.
In the course of the charging course of, electrons circulate from the anode to the cathode inducing a switch of the lithium ions from the cathode to the anode. The other response occurs throughout discharge.
Are hydrogen gas cells extra environment friendly than lithium-ion batteries?
The effectivity of a hydrogen gas cell is round 50%. In different phrases, 50% of the hydrogen equipped to the gas cell is successfully transformed into electrical energy.
The effectivity of a lithium-ion battery is round 98%. Practically all electrons that undergo the battery are successfully saved and launched (cost and discharge).
Nonetheless, maintain in my thoughts that we can’t straight evaluate the effectivity of a gas cell and a lithium-ion battery. Certainly, the gas cell generates electrical energy from a major vitality supply (hydrogen), and the battery shops electrical energy and wishes an exterior supply of electrical energy to be charged.
Hydrogen gas cells vs. lithium-ion batteries: Infrastructure
Undoubtedly, electrical automobiles will take over our conventional combustion engines within the close to future.
For this vitality revolution to grow to be a actuality, large infrastructure investments are wanted.
The developments are primarily targeted on the next:
- Manufacturing amenities.
- Distribution system.
- Charging station.
Within the chart beneath, we’ve summarized the infrastructures wanted for each applied sciences:
| Hydrogen gas cells | Li-ion batteries | |
|---|---|---|
| Manufacturing amenities | Hydrogen manufacturing vegetation | Energy vegetation |
| Distribution system | Pipes and tanks | Electrical transmission strains |
| Charging station | Hydrogen refilling station | Charging stations |
Li-ion batteries infrastructure
Though fairly current, Li-ion is essentially the most mature know-how.
The primary problem with EVs is to provide electrical energy rapidly to a number of places.
In 2022, the common EV battery dimension is 50kWh, with a charging time (10%-80%) of 35 minutes on a fast charging station vs. 7 minutes on a full fuel tank. That is the weak level of electrical automobiles: the slowness of charging.
This technical drawback is a large problem for engineers. On the one hand, they’re making an attempt to enhance batteries to simply accept greater charging energy. Alternatively, they’re dealing with the technical problem of supplying high-power charging stations.
Presently, the Tesla supercharger reaches 250kW, and your EV will get 200 miles of additional autonomy in quarter-hour. That is nonetheless very removed from our petrol vehicles. To chop the recharge time by 2, we would wish a 500kW supercharger.
Now let’s do a easy calculation, if 5 vehicles are linked to a charging station, the moment energy wanted is 2.5MW.
There are greater than 140,000 EV chargers within the US (53,000 charging stations). If all charging stations are outfitted with a future 500kW supercharger, the moment energy wanted can be roughly 53’000 x 2.5MW= 132GW.
That is equal to 132 nuclear reactors!
In conclusion, we’d like big investments in new energy vegetation and electrical energy grids for EVs to be massively adopted.
Hydrogen gas cell infrastructures
Popularized by Jeremy Rifkin in his guide the hydrogen financial system (2002). Hydrogen is seen as essentially the most promising candidate to interchange our fossil gas financial system.
Nonetheless, after greater than 20 years, the event of infrastructures continues to be extraordinarily restricted.
Switching from petrol to hydrogen requires large funding in hydrogen manufacturing amenities, distribution, and refilling stations.
Hydrogen doesn’t exist as a pure supply and must be produced. Presently, 98% of hydrogen manufacturing is from fossil fuels. The problem is to change to renewable sources comparable to water electrolysis powered by photo voltaic or wind vitality.
With solely 107 refilling stations within the US, the hydrogen distribution system is extraordinarily restricted. There’s nonetheless a protracted strategy to go earlier than hydrogen and gas cells grow to be a actuality for our automobiles.
Will hydrogen vehicles overtake electrical automobiles?
Over the long run — 30 to 40 years — there’s a likelihood for hydrogen vehicles to overhaul electrical automobiles.
The primary motive is that it’s a lot simpler to retailer and switch hydrogen than electrical energy.
Semi-commercial hydrogen vehicles can already obtain quick refilling, gaining 300 miles in 3 to five minutes, with a complete vary of greater than 840 miles for the Toyota Mirai.
That stated, we’re nonetheless removed from seeing hydrogen gas cells turning into mainstream.
Hydrogen vs. lithium-ion: what does the longer term appear to be?
There isn’t any doubt that the way forward for automotive is electrical, however will our future electrical vehicles be powered by lithium-ion batteries or gas cells?
Though gas cell vehicles can already obtain quick refilling and maintain the identical autonomies as petrol vehicles, it’s doubtless that the know-how won’t take over the EV market but.
To grow to be a actuality, the hydrogen financial system wants big investments throughout all its worth chain within the tons of of billions of {dollars}.
For the subsequent 20 to 30 years, the lithium-ion battery would be the main EV know-how.
Within the close to future, we are able to count on 5 main enhancements for battery-powered EVs:
- Value discount, with the huge adoption of electrical vehicles, the costs are more likely to drop.
- Elevated autonomy by enhancing battery capability.
- Improved security with solid-state battery.
- Extra recharging stations.
- Quick charging.
The final level is essentially the most difficult, can we produce sufficient electrical energy for our electrical vehicles, and might the electrical grid deal with big energy demand?
In line with specialists, it’s potential so long as we rigorously plan the development of recent energy vegetation.
Ultimate ideas
Hydrogen is taken into account the gas of the longer term; it’s extremely energetic and might be produced from renewable vitality and water.
Gasoline cells convert hydrogen into electrical energy and solely emit water and warmth as a by-product.
Huge R&D investments within the early 2000s led to the event of gas cell-powered automobiles that may already obtain quick refilling and lengthy vary.
The primary impediment to this know-how turning into mainstream is the huge infrastructure investments. Because of this, we gained’t see any hydrogen vehicles on our roads earlier than 20 to 30 years.
Alternatively, lithium-ion know-how is massively adopted for EVs. Lithium batteries nonetheless endure from low recharge velocity and restricted autonomy vs. petrol vehicles, however we are able to count on fast enchancment.
Probably the most difficult half is growing charging infrastructures and energy vegetation to refill the tons of of thousands and thousands of EVs that will likely be out on the highway within the subsequent 20 years.
Are you interested by hydrogen and its future functions? We’ve crafted an accessible DIY gas cell challenge to familiarize ourselves with the know-how.
